Back to the on-screen lesson ·

Curly-arrow meaning

A curly arrow moves a pair of electrons from its tail, on a lone pair or bond, to its head, where a bond or lone pair forms; charges follow the arrows, and an arrow never starts on an atom or a positive charge.

Paper packet. Every task here also exists on screen, where it is checked automatically; answers written on paper are not assessed by Nydus. When you are back at a device, enter your answers there.

1. What you will learn

You will say what an arrow shows, read arrowheads, spot wrongly drawn arrows, recount charges after an arrow, and choose the arrows for a one-step substitution.

2. What you already have

You can name the nucleophile and the electrophile in a reaction. A curly arrow draws the step between them: which electrons move and where they go.

3. Words for this lesson

A curly arrow shows a pair of electrons moving, from its tail to its head. A fishhook (half-headed) arrow moves one electron. A mechanism is a reaction written as a sequence of arrows.

4. Tail on electrons, head where they go

Every arrow obeys three rules:

  1. The tail starts on electrons: a lone pair, a sigma bond, or a pi bond. Never on an atom's nucleus or a positive charge, which has no electrons to give.
  2. The head shows where they go: between two atoms, a new bond; on one atom, a new lone pair.
  3. Charges follow: whatever gives a pair becomes one unit more positive; whatever gains a pair, one unit more negative.

In CH3Br + CN− → CH3CN + Br−, one arrow runs from cyanide's lone pair to the carbon (a new C–C bond) and one from the C–Br bond to bromine (the bond breaks, bromine leaves as Br−). Cyanide's −1 is used up; bromine gains it.

Another way: steps

To check an arrow:

  1. Is its tail on a lone pair, a sigma bond or a pi bond?
  2. Does its head end between atoms (new bond) or on one (new lone pair)?
  3. Recount formal charges afterwards.

5. Following charges through arrows

Formal charge bookkeeping checks a mechanism. When water's oxygen gives a lone pair to a carbocation, it goes from two bonds and two lone pairs to three bonds and one lone pair: $6 - 2 - 3 = +1$. The carbon's positive charge has moved onto oxygen, exactly as the arrow predicts. If a mechanism's charges do not add up to the same total before and after each step, an arrow is wrong. Radical reactions use fishhook arrows, each moving one electron, and are a different family of mechanisms.

6. Where this goes wrong

A curly arrow shows an atom physically moving. It shows electrons.

An arrow can start on H+. A proton has no electrons; arrows point to it.

One full arrow moves one electron. It moves two.

Direction doesn't matter. Electrons flow from tail to head.

7. Hydroxide taking a proton from ethanoic acid

  1. Arrow 1: from a lone pair on hydroxide's oxygen to the acidic hydrogen.

    Tail on electrons.

  2. Arrow 2: from the O–H bond of the acid to its oxygen.

    The old bond breaks.

  3. Hydroxide becomes water, and the acid becomes ethanoate with the −1 charge.

    Charges follow the arrows.

8. Your turn: ammonia attacking a proton of H3O+

  1. Where does the first arrow start?

    On ammonia's lone pair.

  2. Where does the second arrow start and end?

  3. Your turn: work this step out. Its working is at the end of the packet.

    From an O–H bond of H3O+ onto its oxygen, giving water.

9. Guided practice

In a mechanism, a curly arrow runs from a lone pair on the oxygen of hydroxide to the carbon of bromomethane. What does it show?

10. Guided practice

Match each feature of an arrow to what it means.

a pair of electrons movesone electron movesa new bond forms therethat atom gains a lone pair
a full, two-barbed arrowhead
a half-headed fishhook arrow
a head ending between two atoms
a head ending on a single atom

11. Practice

A student's mechanism contains four arrows, described below. Mark every arrow that is drawn correctly.

This task has no paper form; do it on a device.

12. Practice

An arrow runs from one lone pair on the oxygen of water to the empty orbital of a carbocation, making a new O–C bond. What is the formal charge on that oxygen afterwards?

Answer:

13. Somewhere new

In the one-step reaction CH3Br + CN− → CH3CN + Br−, which pair of arrows describes it?

14. Lesson test

Lesson test: one question per skill, one attempt each, no hints. Your answers are checked when you submit.

15. Test question

In the addition of HBr to ethene, three arrows are drawn: (1) from the C=C to the H of HBr, (2) from the H–Br bond to Br, (3) from a lone pair on Br− to the carbocation's carbon. Say what kind of electrons each arrow starts on.

starts on
arrow 1
arrow 2
arrow 3

16. What you can do now

You can read a mechanism's arrows. Tell someone why an arrow never starts on H+. Next: what happens between the arrows — intermediates and transition states.

Working for the steps left to you

8. Your turn: ammonia attacking a proton of H3O+, step 3